GameVui123 logo GameVui123Casual games, honestly reviewed
Guides and Tips

How to Spot a Mobile Game Clone Before You Install It

I went looking for a word puzzle a reader had recommended and the search results gave me fourteen apps with almost the same icon, a wooden tile on a green background, and names that differed by one adjective.

A phone screen showing app store search results with several near identical puzzle game icons side by side

I went looking for a word puzzle a reader had recommended and the search results gave me fourteen apps with almost the same icon, a wooden tile on a green background, and names that differed by one adjective. I installed the one with 180,000 ratings because that felt safe. It was the clone. The game my reader meant had 2,400 ratings, a different developer, and none of the three second ads between rounds.

That is the part people get wrong about clones. The copy is frequently the bigger, louder, better reviewed listing, because copying a proven game is cheap and the money saved goes into marketing. Picking the real one is not a matter of trusting the numbers. It is a matter of reading four or five specific things on the listing, which takes about two minutes once you know where they live.

What Actually Counts as a Clone

Lumping everything together makes this harder than it needs to be, so I sort copies into four kinds and only two of them are worth avoiding.

The reskin. Same mechanics, new art, often by a studio that ships a dozen of these a year. Usually functional, usually crammed with ads, rarely updated past the first month. Playable, forgettable.

The straight rip. The original's levels, sounds and sometimes its exact text, pulled from a decompiled build. These are the ones with inconsistent screenshots, where two images use different fonts because they came from different versions. Avoid, and report them.

The public domain build. Solitaire, sudoku, mahjong tiles, dominoes, chess. Nobody owns these rules and there is no original app to be loyal to. A hundred versions of Klondike is not a clone problem, it is a quality problem, and the only question is which build has the layout and ad load you prefer. If you are comparing solitaire apps, skip this whole article and read the listing for ads instead.

The successor. Someone sees a good idea executed badly and does it properly. Plenty of games I recommend started this way. A copy that adds something is not a clone in any sense worth complaining about.

The Developer Page Tells You Most of It

Tap the developer name on the listing. This single screen has resolved more of these questions for me than everything else combined.

Count the apps. A studio with 4 to 15 titles built over several years is normal. A studio with 60 titles, most published within the last eight months, is a factory, and factories do not make the original of anything. I found one last spring with 94 apps and an average of 11 days between releases.

Look at the spread of genres. A real studio has a specialty. The factory has a merge puzzle, a parking game, a bubble shooter, a hair salon and an idle farm, all with the same support email.

Check the support link. A domain that exists, has a privacy page, and mentions the game by name is a good sign. A free form builder page, a bare address, or a link that redirects to the store itself is not. I would weight this more heavily than anything in the reviews.

Here is how I score the signals when two listings look identical.

SignalPoints toward the originalPoints toward the copy
Developer catalog sizeUnder 20 apps, spread over years40 or more, most within a year
First release dateEarlier, with a long update historyLater, often right after a viral moment
ScreenshotsConsistent fonts, interface and languageMixed fonts, stock mockup frames, fake buttons
Update notesSpecific, mentions levels or bug fixes by nameBug fixes and improvements, repeated verbatim
Support websiteReal site with a game pageForm builder, dead link, or none
Rating countUnreliable either wayUnreliable either way
App sizeLarger, real assetsOften under 25 MB with ads streamed in

The screenshot test deserves a mention on its own because it is the fastest. Clones assemble their store images from whatever they have, so the fonts drift, one screenshot shows a currency symbol the others do not, and the interface language changes halfway through the set. Originals are made by someone who cares what the page looks like.

Why Rating Counts Are the Worst Signal You Have

The usual advice is to pick whichever app has more downloads and better reviews. I followed that rule for years and it is how I ended up with the wrong word puzzle.

A clone made by a factory has a user acquisition budget. The original is frequently a two person team that spent its money on the game. Within three months of a hit appearing, the copy can have twenty times the installs, and the rating average will often be a touch higher as well, because an app that prompts for a review at the exact moment you clear a level collects kinder scores than one that asks on launch.

Look at the shape of the reviews rather than the average. Open the three star reviews, which is the habit I argue for in reading app store reviews properly, and look for people saying the game stopped working after an update, or asking where a feature went. Clones do not maintain. Three months after launch a clone has a wall of reviews complaining about crashes on new phone models and nobody answering them.

The other thing I check now is the review timeline. If almost all the reviews arrived in one six week burst and then stopped, that was a marketing push on a product nobody stayed with. Steady reviews across two years mean a game people keep finding.

One honest caveat. I get this wrong perhaps one time in ten, usually because a small studio sold its game to a publisher who then shipped it under a new name, which looks exactly like a clone from the outside. When the signals conflict and I cannot tell, I install the smaller one and keep it for a week. If it is bad I have lost ten minutes.

The Two Minute Routine

This is what I do before installing anything I have not seen reviewed by someone I trust.

Read the title and subtitle for keyword stuffing. Three genre words jammed after the name, something like puzzle match blast adventure, means the listing was written for the search algorithm and not for you. Then tap the developer, count the apps and glance at the dates. Then scroll the screenshots looking only at fonts and interface, not at the art. Then read two three star reviews from the last month.

If all four pass, install it. If the developer page is a factory but the game still looks fun, install it anyway and expect to delete it in a week, which is a perfectly reasonable thing to do with a free game. What I would not do is spend money inside an app that failed the developer check, because the thing most likely to vanish with your purchase is a title from a studio that ships one a fortnight.

Ads and purchases are a separate question from authorship, and a copy with decent manners can be a better evening than an original that walls you in. The warning signs for that are in spotting pay to win before you get hooked. Our other guides and tips go game by game for the ones worth the time.

FAQ

Are clones dangerous or just annoying?

Mostly annoying. The real risk sits in the permissions and the ad networks rather than the copying. If a card game asks for contacts or precise location, that is the thing to walk away from, clone or not.

Search the game name together with the studio name, or look it up outside the store first. The store search ranks on install volume, which is exactly the number the copies have bought.

Does reporting a clone do anything?

Occasionally. Reports that cite copied assets, with screenshots of both, get acted on far more often than reports that say this is a copy of my favourite game. Idea similarity is not something the stores police, and mechanics cannot be owned.

Is the official version always the better game?

No. I have recommended at least four copies over their originals, usually because the newer team fixed the controls or dropped the energy timer. Authorship is a shortcut for judging quality, not a replacement for playing the thing.

ME
Mason Ellery

Mason has picked apart more casual games than he can count, and says plainly which ones are worth your time.

More posts by Mason

More in Guides and Tips

01doorganico 084goad 3hot8 4465456 after5internprogram ahandfulofblessings ahmadpc ahomcybersecurity allodialresources annodex antiquesandperiodcollectibles aotc asianworldkashmir beedlectrics bloggertemplatefree bluefeatheragency bodyweightsolution campaign08blog carfixadvisor catstreetcollective cbstvsports cnfanspurchasing committeeof500yearsofdignityandresistance covertopsdjs cs-kaiyuangame cuestacomunicaciontotal cxoutlet dancebetgame deskgearhub destinyvillastay detectmagazine di33 diamondsteelbuildings donmo dyanadropship emarsysfinance emimattl escapechan eskitarih evautoplay everythingweddings-orlando farmzone feedviewerapp foxstudiosscratch gleasongrade greetingsday hacklabasu haskell iw-kaiyun jagoanproperti jilidskripsi joltbusinessfinance juegodepokergratis juegospucca kaeru-festival latestmehndidesigns lestanzediottaviano litemagazines localcommunityhero lustrsazan mariashebets menswheels newwebstechs1 nikkit ootheday oxigenvpn plurfitness prefetial probudgetcarpetcleaning psychicmrsmartin pyaten qvantor rejoignezlogis rexzbot riselayouts ruchin rwxqsgd5 sakaltime shibiaowang shop-bot skrtips spotlesshaven strcoding tetapatrium topselller uneplanteartificielle vipertechcr webtech1223411 wo-kygaming yamaha-mekar yeknava yoybuysheets zenunwa yamaha-mekar jilidskripsi ankertoto ankertoto ankertoto ankertoto